Tuesday, February 20, 2007

The Drama of Comparative Law

Has comparative law come of age? Peer Zumbansen's recent retrospective on Gunter Frankenberg's 20-year-old "Critical Comparisons" article suggests that comparative law is still struggling with the same conflict that inspired Frankenberg's critique of facile juxtapositions and problem-solving. The former attempts to derive common precepts; the latter, to display different solutions to common problems. Both privilege law and both depend on familiar conceptual paradigms.

One pitfall, or opportunity, that Zumbansen hints at in his article is that the idea of comparative law is itself artificial, as it relies on an intersection between legal systems that may, in reality, meet only between the pages of a comparative journal. In this case, comparative law appears to be a (purely) theoretical dialogue in which the comparative scholar takes both sides. In a way, therefore, the comparative legal enterprise is a dramatic production, with all its artifices and assumed roles that, ideally, creates meaning while not necessarily mimicking reality.