Sunday, March 04, 2007

Access to Justice

Is access to justice the same thing as access to courts? Ontario Chief Justice McMurtry thinks so. In yesterday's online edition of the Toronto Star, he noted that "it's only the relatively affluent, for the most part, who can afford to go through to a trial." The Star then attributed him with saying that "access to justice...is the most important issue facing the legal system." Access to justice initiatives are focused on simplifying procedures, removing "bottlenecks" (some of which were put in place to ensure a fair result), and creating more funding for the legal aid system. These initiatives assume that courts are the centres for justice in our society.

But what if courts only play a supporting role in the performance of justice? Robert Wolfe, a law professor at Queen's University, writes:
a court is not necessarily a central institution for law -- [Fuller] argued that adjudication as 'a social process of decision' depends on decision by a third party after the presentation of proofs and reasoned arguments, a form of participation that serves some ends but not others. Courts have high thresholds for bringing issues before them, Komesar shows, and their formality raises the costs of participation, especially information costs. The nature of the stakes affects what sorts of issues are likely to be adjudicated, and why... Courts can only resolve matters that are brought to them... Courts are one of many social institutions for making collective decisions, not a uniquely authoritative site for determining what is 'legal'... When the only institution that we can imagine is formal adjudication, we limit the way in which we can understand the problem, the scope of participation, and the types of possible outcome.
A better picture of the notion of access to justice would acknowledge that justice is a diffuse process that takes place on various levels. The legislature has as much a duty to provide justice as the courts. So do the various service providers, ombudsmen, tribunals, and boards. Nor is the furtherance of justice restricted to public authorities. Various civil society organizations also play a role in access to justice. Think, for example, of the way in which the Better Business Bureau holds companies to account for the way they treat their customers. In a society where the administrative state is extensive, the economy and social relations are complex, and extra funds are scarce, we need to start thinking outside the four walls of the courtroom if we are going to solve the problem of access to justice.

Thursday, March 01, 2007

Judicial Advisory Committees: Independence at Risk

A letter I sent to a Conservative MP today:

I appreciate hearing your take on changes to the judicial advisory committees. While in general I don't oppose the idea of changes to the system (judges often downplay their political commitments), I wanted to clarify, in writing, my concerns about the recent changes.

The Judicial Advisory Committees were created in 1988 in response to concerns about large numbers of Liberal party loyalists being appointed to the judiciary in the wake of Trudeau's loss. The committees were meant to place judicial appointments at one remove from government, and ensure that candidates were selected on their merits. Therefore, the federal government was given a minority voice on the committee, with the balance selected and held by the legal community.

The recent changes appear to upset that balance: the federal government now has a majority voice on the committee. I agree that the law enforcement community should have a voice, but I don't think its voice should have come at the expense of the judiciary's vote. The former Minister of Justice stated that the goal of the changes was to "expand the pool of consultation." However, it seems more likely that the changes were meant to, as Prime Minister Stephen Harper suggested, "make sure that we crack down on crime." Will it only be judges who are publicly motivated to "crack down on crime" who are appointed? And, under a different government, will it only be judges who are known to be "progressive" who are appointed?

It does seem to me that the changes, as implemented, will tend to signal to prospective and current judges that their discretion should be exercised in line with current government policy. It certainly does not amount to telling judges what to decide in particular cases, but the changes do appear to undermine the principle of judicial independence.

I remember asking an older judge, who was also a long-time member of the Salvation Army church, what he thought of mandatory minimum sentences or the "one strike, you're out" approach. He said, "I don't think much of them," and explained that judges have to consider the wide variety of circumstances in which accused persons find themselves. The hardened criminal is one situation but, he asked me, what do you do with the 18-year-old kid who's made a mistake, or fallen in with a bad crowd? Is a mandatory prison term the best solution for them?

People run afoul of the law for all kinds of reasons, and the uniqueness of these situations is the reason for giving judges discretion. I just can't see how implementing a general government policy of being "tough on crime" through the back door of appointments will lead to greater justice for Canadians.