Wednesday, November 01, 2006

Filling the Regulatory Vacuum: Part 2

I may have shortchanged the last paragraph of the previous post to avoid getting into a (much longer) discussion of the preconditions for the question of democratic legitimacy. I would not want to leave politics or law out of the discussion; of course the standards-making process must be legitimate. But, in response to some grief over my setting aside of the question of democratic legitimacy, my points could be revised as follows:
  1. Western states have strong and thick administrative structures that are "legitimate" and often, in practice, unassailable; however, it is not usually the presence of these structures that lead to criticisms of the "democratic deficit". Rather, transparency and accountability are key factors in judging whether or not an administration (as opposed to a government) is legitimate.
  2. Developing states (often) have weak or thin administrative structures, and those structures that do exist are quite often highly contested (i.e. "the emperor is far away").
  3. All states are sovereign, which means, first, they are stuck with their administrative strengths and/or weaknesses and, second, they cannot fix the weaknesses of other states without "intruding."
  4. TNCs operate across states; therefore, they can take advantage of both the limited jurisdiction of the strong states and the limited laws or powers of enforcement within the weak state.
  5. Transnational regulatory systems also operate across states to address the regulatory vacuum of point #4 -- while both political (maybe even a type of colonization) and legal (they are comprised of rules and enforcement), they bypass but do not replace that particular political-legal container known as the state. If there are questions regarding their democratic legitimacy, they only mirror the questions of democratic legitimacy within the strong administrative state.
  6. The questions are complicated by the fact that transnational regulatory systems cross sovereign boundaries precisely for the purpose of making TNCs or even states accountable to strong, though sector-based, administrative regimes that are influenced neither by government agendas nor by market forces. The driving force behind these regulatory systems lies within that elusive domain of civil society, with its admixture of politics, morality, economics, etc.
I think these six elements lead to the conclusion that, while the question of democratic legitimacy may be relevant, it can only come after the questions regarding the nature of sovereignty, the modes of politics, and transparency and participation within non-state rule-making processes. These questions have the advantage that they can be addressed independent of whether or not a given state is democratic (a condition that would undermine any discussion of democratic legitimacy).

No comments: